Fewer SEC Enforcement Actions, But the Risks Haven’t Disappeared
Featured In: FundFire
Shane McGreevy, Compliance Consultant at STP Investment Services, was featured in a recent FundFire article examining the SEC’s fiscal 2026 enforcement results and what the agency’s declining case totals may signal for investment managers and compliance teams.
The SEC brought 348 enforcement actions during fiscal 2026, 24% fewer than in 2025, and ordered approximately $1.1 billion in monetary relief, including $343 million in civil penalties and $752 million in disgorgement and prejudgment interest. At the same time, the agency returned $731 million to approximately 250,000 harmed investors.
Read the original article on FundFire.
The Bigger Picture
SEC enforcement activity continued its decline in fiscal 2026.
The agency brought 348 enforcement actions, down from 456 in 2025. Standalone actions declined 22%, while total monetary relief fell significantly compared with the prior year. The year-over-year monetary comparison is influenced by the unusually large Stanford International Bank judgment included in the prior year’s totals.
The numbers, however, tell only part of the story.
The SEC has described its current approach as moving away from “regulation by enforcement” and toward greater emphasis on fraud, market manipulation, and conduct resulting in real investor harm. SEC leadership has also argued that enforcement effectiveness should not be measured solely by the total number of cases or penalties.
For investment managers, that means declining totals should not be interpreted as permission to relax compliance controls.
The agency continued pursuing significant cases involving investment managers, anti-money laundering failures, fraudulent investment advisers, private funds, and emerging technology scams during fiscal 2026.
Key Takeaways
- The SEC brought 348 enforcement actions in fiscal 2026, down 24% from 2025.
- The agency ordered approximately $1.1 billion in monetary relief during the fiscal year.
- Approximately $731 million was returned to 250,000 harmed investors.
- SEC leadership is emphasizing enforcement focused on fraud, market manipulation, and investor harm rather than case volume alone.
- Private funds and the pre-IPO secondary market remain areas where enforcement activity can occur as investor access to alternatives expands.
- Private credit and structured-finance managers should continue emphasizing collateral integrity, verification, and accurate representations.
- Senior individuals can face enforcement exposure alongside corporate entities.
Shane McGreevy’s Perspective
One of the enforcement cases highlighted in the article involved the collapse of a subprime auto lender, where the SEC charged three former senior executives with fraud. The case provides an important lesson for private credit and structured-finance managers.
As Shane McGreevy explained:
“For private credit and structured-finance managers, the lesson is straightforward: collateral integrity, independent verification and accurate representations to financing counterparties are critical controls to evidence.”
— Shane McGreevy, Compliance Consultant, STP Investment Services
What This Means for Investment Managers
A decline in SEC enforcement totals does not eliminate the need for strong compliance programs. Instead, a more selective enforcement environment may increase the importance of understanding where regulators see the greatest potential for actual investor harm.
For private credit and structured-finance managers, controls surrounding collateral and underlying assets are particularly important. Firms should be able to demonstrate how collateral information is validated, how exceptions are escalated, and how information communicated to financing counterparties is verified.
The article also reinforces the importance of individual accountability.
When the SEC identifies potentially fraudulent activity or significant control failures, enforcement exposure may extend beyond the organization to executives and other senior individuals involved in the conduct.
As access to alternative investments expands, private fund managers should also recognize that investor sophistication does not remove regulatory expectations. The article notes that enforcement activity continued in the private fund and pre-IPO market during 2026.
Action Steps for Compliance Leaders
Based on the enforcement themes discussed in the article, firms may want to consider:
- Review collateral verification controls. Ensure underlying collateral and supporting information can be independently substantiated.
- Evaluate representations to counterparties. Confirm that communications regarding assets, collateral, and financing arrangements are accurate and appropriately supported.
- Document control effectiveness. Maintain evidence showing that critical controls operate in practice, not simply that policies exist.
- Review escalation procedures. Establish clear processes for addressing discrepancies, unusual activity, or potentially inaccurate information.
- Evaluate senior management oversight. Ensure appropriate governance and accountability exist around higher-risk business activities.
- Monitor private market risks. Consider how expanding investor access to alternatives affects disclosures, controls, and investor-protection considerations.
- Maintain strong fraud and AML controls. The SEC continued pursuing cases involving fraud, investment scams, and anti-money laundering failures during fiscal 2026.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much did SEC enforcement activity decline in 2026?
The SEC brought 348 enforcement actions in fiscal 2026, 24% fewer than the 456 actions reported for 2025.
Does fewer enforcement activity mean less regulatory scrutiny?
Not necessarily. The article reports that the SEC is shifting toward a more selective approach emphasizing fraud, market manipulation, and cases involving investor harm. Industry experts quoted in the article caution that declining case totals do not equate to reduced scrutiny.
What areas remain important for private fund managers?
The article highlights private fund misconduct, the pre-IPO secondary market, private credit, structured finance, collateral integrity, and investor protection.
What controls are particularly important for private credit managers?
Shane McGreevy specifically identifies collateral integrity, independent verification, and accurate representations to financing counterparties as critical controls to evidence.
Can individuals face SEC enforcement actions?
Yes. Shane McGreevy notes that recent activity demonstrates the SEC’s willingness to pursue senior individuals rather than limiting enforcement to corporate entities.
What does “quality over quantity” mean for SEC enforcement?
The article describes an enforcement philosophy that places less emphasis on the raw number of cases and greater emphasis on investor harm, deterrence, remediation, individuals charged, and enforcement outcomes.
Why It Matters
A 24% decline in enforcement actions can easily be interpreted as a sign of reduced regulatory pressure. For investment managers, that may be the wrong takeaway.
The SEC’s fiscal 2026 activity suggests a more selective enforcement environment where fraud, investor harm, private-market misconduct, and meaningful control failures can still attract significant attention.
For compliance teams, the goal should not be to react to enforcement volume. It should be to maintain controls that can be demonstrated, documented, and defended when scrutiny does occur.